Panel discussion: Towards better regulation of security and defence procurement

We are organising a panel discussion ”Towards better regulation of public and confidential procurement in the security and defence sector”, on Friday, 16 November, 2018, at the PR Centre, starting at 11am.

The panel discussion will focus on public and confidential procurement in the Ministry of Interior and the Police Administration, which spent over 50 million euro in public procurement over the period 2013-2017, and nearly 5 million euro for confidential procurement.

The purpose of the panel discussion is to, in the light of the future independence of the Police Administration and in the context of the preparation of the new Law on Public Procurement, highlight the issues identified in the procurement process in these institutions, as well as good practices, and define recommendations for improving the procedures and regulation for this significant part of public spending.

We will discuss following topics:

– How Ministry of Interior and the Police Administration planned and managed the money for public procurement in the previous five years?

– Until when the confidential procurement in the security and defence sector will be in legal vacuum and far from control?

– Why the by-laws and internal acts envisaged by the Law on Public Procurement from June 2017, which were supposed to better regulate this area, were not adopted?

– Can we miss out the opportunity to regulate the procurement in the security and defence sector by the new Public Procurement Law? What are the recommendations of SIGMA and the European Commission in this regard?

These topics will be addressed by:

Radmila Jakšić, Head of Department for Financial, General and Auxiliary Affairs, Ministry of Interior,

Blažo Savković, Head of Sector II, State Audit Institution,

Mersad Mujević, Director of the Public Procurement Administration and Head of the Working Group for the preparation of the new Law on Public Procurement,

Stefan Šaponjić, Head of the Public Procurement Department and a member of the Working Group for preparation of the Decree on Procurement in the Security and Defence Sector

Discussion will be moderated by Ana Đurnić, public policy researcher at Institute Alternative.

We organise the panel discussion with the support of the European Union through the Civil Society Facility Programme within the project ”Western Balkans Pulse for Police Integrity and Trust: POINTPULSE’’, which has been implemented by the Institute Alternative, together with partners from the region, for four years now.

Money Watch Small Grants Facility – Extended Deadline for Applications!

We inform the interested CSOs that the application deadline for the Small Grants Facility within the project “Money Watch – Civil Society Guarding the Budget” has been extended until 20 November 2018. Complete applications should be sent to e-mail: info@institut-alternativa.org .

CSOs which have already submitted their project proposal and full application are not obliged to do it again.

In order to be eligible for a grant, the applicants must:

  • be a legal person;
  • be non-profit making;
  • be directly responsible for the preparation and management of the action with the co-applicant(s) and affiliated entity(ies), not acting as an intermediary;
  • be registered in Montenegro at least 12 months prior to the deadline for submission of project proposals and
  • have an annual turnover of more than EUR 10,000 in 2016 or 2017.

If only one organisation applies for the grant, its annual turnover in 2016 or 2017 should be above 10.000 euro. If more then one organisation applies for the grant (lead applicants and partner(s)), their cumulative turnover in 2016 or 2017 should be above 10.000 euro.

To apply for grants, following documents should be completed and submitted: Application Form, Budget proposal and Logical framework.

Before completing these forms, please carefully read Guidelines for applicants.

For sub-grantees, we have prepared capacity-building programme in project management and public spending oversight, aimed at contributing to successful implementation of their projects and their future work in this area.

Supported by the EU Delegation in Montenegro, IA has ensured 85.000 euro for this Small Grants Facility. Individual grants requested under this Call for proposals must fall between 8.000 EUR and 10.000 EUR.

Note: Organisations which have already received two sub-grants or are direct beneficiaries through the IPA 2016 Civil Society Facility Montenegro Programme EuropeAid/153998/DD/ACT/MECSF are not eligible to apply.

Project “Money Watch – Civil Society Guarding the Budget” is being implemented by Institute Alternative, in partnership with Institute of Public Finance from Zagreb and NGO New Horizon from Ulcinj. The project is financially supported by European Union.

Clarifications – Money Watch Call for Proposals

Within the Call for Proposals for Small Grants Facility within our project Money Watch – Civil Society Guarding the Budget, we have received the following question:

Q: Are there any restrictions for the sub-grantees supported within the ReLOaD project, to apply for this Call for Proposals under CSF 2016 Programme?

A: No. CSOs whose projects have been already supported within ReLOaD project sub-granting scheme can also apply to our Call for Proposals for Small Grants Facility within our project Money Watch – Civil Society Guarding the Budget. The sources for funding these two projects are diverse, i.e. they are supported through different IPA Programs.

ReLOaD project is being financed through the Civil Society Facility and Media Programme, IPA 2016/038-960, while Money Watch – Civil Society Guarding the Budget is being financed through the Civil Society Facility Montenegro Programme – EuropeAid/153998/DD/ACT/ME.

Please be reminded that the application deadline is 15 November 2018, until 5 PM. Applications should be sent via e-mail info@institut-alternativa.org.

Clarifications and answers to all the question we have received within this Call for Proposals could be found here (only in Montenegrin).

Project “Money Watch – Civil Society Guarding the Budget” is being implemented by Institute Alternative, in partnership with Institute of Public Finance from Zagreb and NGO New Horizon from Ulcinj. The project is financially supported by European Union.

Proposals for the SAI Audit Plan

State Audit Institution is currently preparing an audit plan for the next year. SAI is independent and free to choose audits as it wants, but that doesn’t mean they can not get suggestions from others.

SAI may audit not only individual institutions but also certain policies, such as collecting of fees for forest concessions or energy efficiency in institutions.

Suggest which ministries, administrations, funds, state-owned enterprises, institutions, municipalities or special policies should be monitored next year by the State Audit Institution.

Tell us who the state auditors should visit next and why, and we will consolidate the civil society proposals and refer it to SAI.

Citizens believe that the fight against the corruption in police is ineffective

PR Press service, Podgorica – Despite a stable trust in police, citizens believe that the state is insufficiently effective in fighting corruption, according to the Institute alternative’s research.

Ipsos Strategic Marketing conducted a field research in September of this year, for the needs of Institute alternative, on a sample of 1,013 adult citizens of Montenegro.

At a press conference on the presentation of the results of the survey ”What do citizens think of the police – is it serving the citizens or someone else?”, Aleksandra Vavić, public policy researcher at IA, said that trust in police services throughout the region is not stable.

”In Montenegro, as in Serbia, we have a slow growth, but it exists. On the other side, we can see that during these four years in Kosovo, there has been a high growth of trust in police from 56 percent to 86 percent this year. In Bosnia and Herzegovina, confidence is oscillating a lot from year to year, while in Macedonia and Albania we can see that there is a significant drop in trust in the police”, said Vavić at PR Centre.

According to her, when it comes to trust in institutions, citizens of the Western Balkans believe the most in the education system, while the police is in the second place, and the healthcare is on the third place.

”In Montenegro, police is on the third and healthcare is on the second place, when measuring the trust of the citizens. In general, when we look at the region, the lowest level of trust of the citizens has Anti-corruption Agency, Commercial inspectorates and Parliaments in the countries of the region”, said Vavić.

She said that there is increased trust in education and in healthcare systems in Montenegro, while in Albania and Macedonia there is a significant drop in trust in the police, education system, local authorities, media, etc.

”There has been a significant increase of the trust in police in Kosovo”, said Vavić.

She said, that for the first time survey measured the perception of safety of the citizens.

”The citizens of Montenegro and Serbia feel safe to a higher extent than citizens of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kosovo and Macedonia, while the citizens of Albania stand out – 45% of them do not feel safe. From 20 to 30 percent of citizens in each state could not clearly answer this question and they said that they feel neither unsafe nor safe”, said Vavić.

She said that they asked the citizens who do they trust the most to protect them, stating that the findings of the research showed that the citizens of the Western Balkans dominantly believe the most in themselves.

”42% of the citizens in Serbia thinks this way, 43% in Montenegro, 41% in Bosnia and Herzegovina, 48% in Kosovo, 67% in Albania and 41% in Macedonia”, said Vavić. About 20% of citizens believe that the police is the one to protect them, while less than ten percent of citizens in all countries believe that the army is the institution that will protect them.

”The number of the citizens who said that they do not trust anyone is not negligible, and that percentage ranges from ten percent in Montenegro, to the highest in Macedonia – 24 percent” said Vavić.

She said that the survey showed that the citizens of Kosovo have the most affirmative attitude towards the work of the police – 22 percent are very satisfied, 56 percent are mostly satisfied, explaining that this means that close to 80 percent of Kosovo citizens are generally satisfied with the work of their police.

”On the other hand, about 50 percent of citizens in Albania and Macedonia are either not satisfied at all or mostly dissatisfied with the work of the police in their countries. In Montenegro, 14% are not satisfied at all, 19% are mostly dissatisfied, and 46% are mostly satisfied”, pointed out Vavić.

According to her, in all the countries of the region, citizens still think that a public competition is not the most dominant and most common way of getting a job in the police service.

”We have 44% of citizens of Montenegro who think that the candidates for police force are selected through the public competition, but we have 40% of those who believe that it is necessary to pull friends and family strings in order to get a job, 26% of those who consider that through political connections one can get a job, while 13% thinks that a bribery is needed”, said Vavić.

She said that almost half of the Kosovo’s citizens that police works in the interests of the citizens, followed by Montenegro with 41%, Serbia with 37%, Albania with 35%, Macedonia and Bosnia and Herzegovina with 26%.

”We have an interesting trend in Montenegro – although the number of those who think that the police mostly protects the Government is decreased, the number of those who think that police mostly works in in the interests of the highest police officials has increased”, said Vavić.

According to her, in every county in region, less than 50% of citizens consider that the police works as a service of the citizens.

”Every fourth person in Montenegro (25% of the citizens) believes that politicians have a full influence on the operating work of the police. There have been no significant changes compared to the previous year, as it is the case in other countries. Last year, about 25% of Albanian citizens thought that politics had a full impact on the police, while this year the percentage raised to half of the population”, said Vavić.

She pointed out that, although the number of the citizens in Montenegro who believe that corruption is very and mostly widespread has decreased, over 50% of citizens thinks that corruption exists.

‘’In every county of the region, over half of the citizens believe that corruption in the police exists’’, said Vavić.

Speaking about the perception of corruption in other institutions, Vavić said that citizens believe that corruption is the highest in Judiciary and Healthcare, while the NGO’s sector is in the last place.

”In every county, at least 50% of the citizens thinks that corruption is damaging the work of the police. The perception of the citizens of Albania is the worst, with 73% of those who think it is very damaging, while in Montenegro we have 13% of citizens who think that it is not damaging at all”, said Vavić.